Moving from balanced literacy to a more structured approach

I was a committed balanced literacy educator for 20 years.

To me, balanced literacy meant that I taught both basic skills and a love of reading.

I put a greater emphasis on the activities – shared reading, guided reading, independent reading, read aloud, and centers – than on foundational skills.

Sure, I taught phonics … but I didn’t want to overdo it. So I didn’t use a phonics program; I taught phonics on a need-to-know basis.

Instead of giving explicit instruction, I had my students read independently for long periods while I gave short one-on-one conferences.

I was passionate about balanced literacy.

It’s the approach I learned in graduate school. It’s what I used to teach my first and second graders to read.

It’s the approach I used to teach my oldest five kids to read.

It’s what I thought other teachers should use (and I told them so through multiple blog posts and workshops).

I thought it worked (it sure seemed to).

It wasn’t until I read Emily Hanford’s viral article a few times that I started to wonder if I needed to rethink my approach.

I wish I could tell you that the first time I read the article, my eyes were opened. But I was stubborn, and it was more than a year before I took it to heart.

The first thing I questioned was three-cueing …

Once I understood how the brain learns to read, I began to realize that three-cueing (having kids “guess” words using just the first letter, pictures, or context) was actually bypassing an important process called orthographic mapping.

In other words … I wasn’t helping my students remember the words for the future.

And by my lack of explicit phonics instruction, I almost guaranteed that some of my students would hit a wall in later grades when they lacked strategies for reading multi-syllable words in books without pictures or helpful context.

As I studied structured literacy, I began to see the differences between what I’d been doing and what an approach backed by research looks like.

I began to make quite a few changes …

• I stopped leaving phonemic awareness to chance.
• I started using decodable instead of leveled text.
• I created a systematic, sequential phonics scope and sequence … and actually used it.
• I integrated spelling with phonics instruction.
• I found a new way to teach “sight words.”
• I began to look at comprehension in a different way.
• For the first time, I saw the incredible value of explicit instruction.
  

And all along the way, I was encouraged that thousands of other teachers were making the switch!

In fact, I interviewed some of them for my Balanced to Structured Literacy podcast series:

• Savannah Campbell from Campbell Creates Readers
• Christina Winter from Mrs. Winter’s Bliss
• Heidi Jane from Droppin’ Knowledge with Heidi
• Lindsay Kemeny, podcast host and classroom teacher
• Jessica Farmer from Farmer Loves Phonics
• Gina from Get Literacy
• Margaret Goldberg from the Right to Read Project
• Sarah Paul from Sarah’s Teaching Snippets
• Jan Burkins and Kari Yates, authors of Shifting the Balance
• Dr. Wendy Farone, LETRS trainer, Title 1 reading specialist (and a lot more!)